So, I am in a bit of a pickle.I start my third year of medical school this summer. The third year of school is drastically different from the first two years, as students leave lectures and bookwork behind, to tackle the wards of the hospital. At UCD, every student is required to cycle through 6 required rotations, namely: Surgery, Internal Medicine, Ob/Gyn, Pediatrics, Psychiatry and Family Practice. While the order of these rotations doesn't really matter, there is some benefit to doing some rotations early or deferring some required rotations to your fourth year to do elective rotations (especially if your desired field is a very competitive one).
My problem arises due to a curricular change at UCD SOM. The school decided to switch from a quarter system to a semester system, starting with the current first year medical students. This means that the class below me starts and ends their academic calendar at an earlier date than the classes above them. The problem is that the current first years will start their required third year rotations before my class has completed them. This means that the hospital will have to accommodate twice the number of students on the wards for one rotation block. To ease the strain, the school is requiring 75% of my class to defer our last required rotation to our fourth year, so that the class below us can begin on time.
Without going into too much detail, I've been assigned to defer my Ob/Gyn rotation until November/December of my fourth year. Unless you actually want to be a gynecologist (no thank you), that's a great rotation to have to defer. However, completing the course in the middle (as opposed to the beginning) of the fourth year is a problem. Residency interviews and internships take place during the winter of the fourth year and I'd have to miss significant portions of a required rotation to do that. In order to make up missed time, I'd have to take on extra call and weekend shifts, and worst of all, I'd have to delay taking my Step 2 Board exams for about 6 months (Ob/Gyn is heavily tested).
Since 25% of our class doesn't have to defer, we have the option of "taking my chances" in a lottery of sorts. All those who don't want to defer are being placed in a lottery for the right to complete their third year in the normal fashion. Currently, about 30 students are in this lottery and roughly 20 of them will be able to opt out of deferring a rotation. The other unfortunate 10 will be forced into deferring either Internal Medicine or Surgery, either of which would seriously hurt your chances of getting into good residencies in those fields (pretty much everything but psychiatry). It's risky business, but the odds are in your favor that if you opt for the lottery you won't have to defer.
I am interested in ENT, a surgical specialty, and would not want to have to defer my surgical rotation. Deferring medicine is ridiculous too, because it's such an important rotation. However, my current situation isn't ideal either. So the question is: Do I opt for the lottery and accept a 66.67% chance that my gamble will pay off and I'll get everything I want? And am I willing to accept a 33.33% chance that everything could be ruined? Or do I play it safe and keep what I have and just deal with the annoyance and extra work it will cause? What would you do?


