Today was one of those days in my medical education where I caught myself thinking, "This kind of stuff could only happen in medical school." As I mentioned the other day, today marks the beginning of my Ob/Gyn rotation. I don't actually start doing real work until tomorrow when I report to the L&D department at Sutter Hospital. Today we had our orientation, which was accompanied by instruction from the unsung heroes of the medical world, the standardized patient.
To begin, I must help you to understand that doctors have to begin somewhere. I mean, people trust their docs to do a lot of really peculiar things to their bodies ("Now, if you would just turn your head and cough, sir"), ask them very peculiar and personal questions ("Do you have sex with men, women, or both?"), and basically get away with things that you would otherwise never dream of letting someone do. But would you feel comfortable letting your physician do those things if you knew that he or she had never done them before?
Let's be honest, no one would want to hear their doctor tell them: "For the next part of the exam I am going to need to insert my finger into your rectum. Now, I have never actually done this before, but have seen it performed and think I've got the basic idea. So, if you would just drop your pants and bend over we can get started..."
Nobody wants to be the guinea pig, right?
Well, see, there's where you might be wrong. In order to better help the medical students be able to adequately perform a clinical breast exam, the school arranged for a panel of women (the "standardized patients" or SPs) to come to the school and allow us to practice the skill on them. To help get us a feel for the variations in anatomy from person to person, we spent about 10 minutes at every station assessing and checking each pair of breasts before moving onto the next set. I give the school credit, from the pendulous to the petite and the saggy to the firm, they had assembled a fairly diverse array of breasts.
From an educational standpoint, it really was a unique opportunity--a chance to perform multiple exams in a row and get a sense for what a "normal" exam should be like. However, there were two nagging thoughts that I just couldn't seem to shake: 1) "Wow, under any other circumstances, this would be wildly inappropriate," and 2) "How much are these women getting paid to do this?" [Ed note: The answer to that query is they get paid quite well. If you are interested in becoming a standardized patient at UCD, please click here].
While I found it conceivable that a woman would agree to submit to multiple breast examinations if the price was right, I still have a hard time believing that each of these women also consented to receiving multiple pelvic exams at the hands of know-nothing students. Though I do not possess the necessary plumbing, I can only imagine a few things which might be more uncomfortable. Nevertheless, the SPs were all very friendly, funny, and informative ("No, I am pretty sure that is not an ovary you've got there"). Fortunately for them, we didn't practice doing Pap smears on them. Instead, we practiced that technique on apples (or "Papples," as the instructor liked to call them).
So, the next time your doctor asks you to turn your head and cough or scoot your butt to the edge of a table so that it's hanging off ("no, further, keep going..."), just remember, as uncomfortable as the experience may be, it would be even worse were it not for the sacrifice of the SPs.
On behalf of doctors and patients the world over: Standardized patients, we salute you.
To begin, I must help you to understand that doctors have to begin somewhere. I mean, people trust their docs to do a lot of really peculiar things to their bodies ("Now, if you would just turn your head and cough, sir"), ask them very peculiar and personal questions ("Do you have sex with men, women, or both?"), and basically get away with things that you would otherwise never dream of letting someone do. But would you feel comfortable letting your physician do those things if you knew that he or she had never done them before?
Let's be honest, no one would want to hear their doctor tell them: "For the next part of the exam I am going to need to insert my finger into your rectum. Now, I have never actually done this before, but have seen it performed and think I've got the basic idea. So, if you would just drop your pants and bend over we can get started..."
Nobody wants to be the guinea pig, right?
Well, see, there's where you might be wrong. In order to better help the medical students be able to adequately perform a clinical breast exam, the school arranged for a panel of women (the "standardized patients" or SPs) to come to the school and allow us to practice the skill on them. To help get us a feel for the variations in anatomy from person to person, we spent about 10 minutes at every station assessing and checking each pair of breasts before moving onto the next set. I give the school credit, from the pendulous to the petite and the saggy to the firm, they had assembled a fairly diverse array of breasts.
From an educational standpoint, it really was a unique opportunity--a chance to perform multiple exams in a row and get a sense for what a "normal" exam should be like. However, there were two nagging thoughts that I just couldn't seem to shake: 1) "Wow, under any other circumstances, this would be wildly inappropriate," and 2) "How much are these women getting paid to do this?" [Ed note: The answer to that query is they get paid quite well. If you are interested in becoming a standardized patient at UCD, please click here].
While I found it conceivable that a woman would agree to submit to multiple breast examinations if the price was right, I still have a hard time believing that each of these women also consented to receiving multiple pelvic exams at the hands of know-nothing students. Though I do not possess the necessary plumbing, I can only imagine a few things which might be more uncomfortable. Nevertheless, the SPs were all very friendly, funny, and informative ("No, I am pretty sure that is not an ovary you've got there"). Fortunately for them, we didn't practice doing Pap smears on them. Instead, we practiced that technique on apples (or "Papples," as the instructor liked to call them).
So, the next time your doctor asks you to turn your head and cough or scoot your butt to the edge of a table so that it's hanging off ("no, further, keep going..."), just remember, as uncomfortable as the experience may be, it would be even worse were it not for the sacrifice of the SPs.
On behalf of doctors and patients the world over: Standardized patients, we salute you.






